FeaturedKuwait News

Kuwait Court Rulings Set Boundaries on Regulatory Powers Over Digital Delivery Platforms

By Abdulmohsen Yaqoub AlSanea
Lawyer, Dr. Yaqoub Al Sanea & Partners Law Firm and Legal Consultancy
Special to The Times Kuwait


Kuwait’s expanding digital commerce sector has brought convenience to consumers and created new business opportunities for restaurants, retailers and technology companies. However, the rapid growth of electronic delivery platforms has also raised important questions about the limits of government regulation, particularly when administrative decisions have far-reaching consequences for businesses.

Recent first-instance judgments issued by Kuwait’s Administrative Court during September and October 2026 have brought this issue into focus, following the annulment of Article 15 of the Regulation governing electronic platforms and applications involved in displaying, ordering and delivering products to consumers.

The rulings highlight a fundamental legal principle: while administrative authorities have the power to regulate commercial activities within their statutory mandate, they cannot introduce punitive measures without an express legislative basis. The issue has wider implications for Kuwait’s digital economy, the relationship between regulators and businesses, and the country’s efforts to establish a transparent and predictable commercial environment.

A regulatory framework for digital delivery

On July 8, 2026, the Minister of Commerce and Industry issued Ministerial Resolution No. 109 of 2026, introducing regulations governing electronic platforms and applications acting as intermediaries between consumers and businesses. The resolution replaced Ministerial Resolution No. 10 of 2026, which had previously regulated the delivery of restaurant orders and prepared food.

The new regulation sought to establish a more comprehensive framework for the sector. Its provisions included maximum commission rates and delivery fees, contractual obligations between platforms and participating restaurants and stores, and mechanisms for handling complaints and violations.

The objective was to balance the interests of digital platforms, commercial establishments and consumers while ensuring that the rapidly expanding electronic commerce sector operated within an appropriate regulatory environment. However, the implementation of the regulation raised questions about the extent of the Ministry’s authority to impose administrative penalties, particularly measures that could threaten the continued operation of businesses.

Why Article 15 became controversial

Article 15 established a graduated system of administrative sanctions for violations of the regulation. These included warnings, administrative closure, suspension of business activities, temporary blocking of electronic platforms and, in more serious or repeated cases, cancellation of licences and permanent blocking.

The legal challenge centred on whether the Minister of Commerce and Industry possessed sufficient legislative authority to introduce such measures through a ministerial resolution. During September and October 2026, the Administrative Court issued first-instance judgments annulling Article 15 in cases brought by companies operating in the electronic platform sector.

The central issue was the distinction between the authority to regulate commercial activities and the authority to impose punitive sanctions. Under the principle of legality, administrative authorities must exercise their powers within the limits established by legislation.

A ministerial resolution may introduce rules necessary to implement an existing law, but it cannot independently create additional punitive powers that the legislature has not authorised. The distinction becomes particularly important when sanctions involve closing businesses, suspending commercial operations or cancelling licences, all of which can have significant economic and legal consequences.

It is also important to note that the judgments discussed in the legal study were issued at first instance. Their final legal consequences remain subject to the outcome of any appeals and the applicable rules governing the enforcement and binding effect of annulment judgments.

Regulation does not automatically confer punitive powers

One of the most significant aspects of the legal analysis concerns Decree-Law No. 10 of 1979, as amended, relating to the supervision of trade in goods, services and craft activities and the determination of certain prices. This legislation provides the Ministry of Commerce and Industry with powers to supervise and regulate specified commercial activities and services. It also contains provisions dealing with violations, penalties and temporary administrative closure, including Articles 13 and 15 and Article 12 bis.

The legal argument is that where the legislature has already established a framework for violations and penalties, the administration must operate within that framework rather than create a parallel system of sanctions through a ministerial resolution.

Even when sanctions are introduced in graduated stages according to the seriousness or recurrence of violations, this does not automatically make them lawful. Proportionality is important, but it cannot replace the requirement for explicit legislative authorisation. In other words, the authority to regulate an economic activity should not be interpreted as an unrestricted power to punish businesses.

What happens to the remaining regulations?

The annulment of Article 15 does not automatically invalidate the other provisions of Ministerial Resolution No. 109 of 2026. This distinction is particularly important for delivery platforms, restaurants and retailers. Provisions relating to maximum commission rates, delivery fees, contractual relationships and other regulatory obligations remain in place, provided they were not included within the scope of the court judgments.

However, their continued existence does not mean that they are immune from judicial scrutiny. Their legality can still be challenged if they are found to exceed the statutory authority granted to the Ministry. The annulment of the sanctions provision therefore affects the administrative enforcement mechanisms available under the regulation, but does not eliminate the underlying obligations or exempt businesses from liability under other applicable laws.

Other laws remain applicable

The legal study also examines whether other legislation can be used to address violations committed by electronic delivery platforms. The answer is yes, but only where the specific requirements of the relevant legislation are satisfied.

Under Law No. 72 of 2020 concerning the Protection of Competition, the Competition Protection Authority can address prohibited practices, including agreements restricting competition and abuse of a dominant market position. However, a breach of the delivery platform regulation does not automatically constitute a competition violation. Authorities must establish the existence of a dominant position, prohibited conduct and the other legal elements required under the competition law.

Similarly, Law No. 39 of 2014 concerning Consumer Protection, as amended, remains applicable where practices involve consumer deception or infringement of legally protected consumer rights.

Nevertheless, disputes arising exclusively from contractual or commercial relationships between a platform and a restaurant cannot automatically be classified as consumer protection violations.

Commercial licensing legislation also continues to apply within its prescribed scope. Any measure affecting a business licence or the continuity of commercial operations must have an express statutory basis and follow the required legal procedures. The important principle is that other laws cannot be used simply to reintroduce sanctions that have been annulled by the court under a different regulatory framework.

The significance of the Digital Commerce Law

Another important development is Decree-Law No. 10 of 2026 concerning the Regulation of Activities in the Digital Commerce Sector. The legislation provides a broader framework covering commercial activities conducted through digital means, obligations imposed on providers of products and services, consumer protection, supervision, violations and sanctions.

However, Article 45 provides that the law will enter into force one month after publication of its Executive Regulation in the Official Gazette. This means that the enactment of the legislation and its actual commencement are two separate legal stages. Its procedural and punitive provisions cannot be relied upon before the prescribed effective date.

The law also provides for measures such as temporary blocking, subject to the conditions and powers established in its provisions. Completing the Executive Regulation and bringing the legislation into force will therefore be important in establishing clarity over the responsibilities of regulatory authorities and the enforcement mechanisms available to them.

The way forward for Kuwait’s digital economy

The legal disputes surrounding Article 15 provide an opportunity to strengthen Kuwait’s regulatory framework for digital commerce. As electronic platforms become increasingly important to the economy, the government must ensure that regulation keeps pace with technological developments and changing commercial practices. At the same time, businesses require clarity about their obligations, the consequences of non-compliance and the legal authority under which sanctions may be imposed.




Follow The Times Kuwait on X, Instagram, Facebook and Whatsapp Channel for the latest news updates


 






Read Today's News TODAY...
on our Telegram Channel
click here to join and receive all the latest updates t.me/thetimeskuwait



Back to top button