Forgot your password?



Back to login

Economic factors influence parenting style
October 15, 2017, 4:11 pm
Share/Bookmark

Deciding on a parenting style is often challenging. Is it better to be strict or more lenient? Is ‘helicopter parenting’ the right approach to guiding their children's choices? A new study at Yale University argues that modern parenting styles are shaped by economic factors that incentivize one strategy over others.

The study asserts that parents are driven by a combination of altruism — a desire for their children to succeed — and paternalism that leads them to try to influence their children's choices, either by molding their children's preferences or restricting them. These motivations manifest in three parenting styles: A permissive style that affords children the freedom to follow their inclinations and learn from their own experiences; an authoritative style in which parents try to mold their children's preferences to induce choices consistent with the parents' notions of achieving success; and an authoritarian style in which parents impose their will on their children and control their choices.

The researchers, postulating that socioeconomic conditions drive how much control or monitoring parents exercise on their children's choices, applied their model across time periods and countries. They found that parenting became more permissive in the 1960s and 1970s when economic inequality reached historic lows in industrialized countries and parents could realize a return on letting children learn from their own experiences. Across countries, they document a link between parenting, on the one hand, and income inequality and return to education, on the other hand.

Using the World Value Survey, where people are asked which attitudes or values they find most important in child rearing, they identify permissive parents with those emphasizing the values of imagination and independence in rearing children, whereas authoritarian and authoritative parents are those who insist on the importance of hard work and obedience, respectively. They show that parents in more unequal countries are less permissive. The same pattern emerges when they consider redistributive policies. In countries with more redistributive taxation, more social expenditure, and even stronger civil right protection, parents are significantly more permissive.

The researchers assert that their theory can help explain the recent rise of ‘helicopter parenting’, a version of the authoritative style in which parents seek to influence their children's choices with a combination of persuasion and intensive monitoring. They argue that the style gained hold in the United States as economic inequality increased, inducing a shift to more intensive parenting to strengthen children's drive for achievement and prevent them from risky behaviors. Meanwhile, they argue, more permissive parenting remains popular in Scandinavian countries, where inequality is lower than it is in the United States.

 

Share your views
CAPTCHA
 

"It is hard to fail, but it is worse never to have tried to succeed."

"Envy comes from wanting something that isn't yours. But grief comes from losing something you've already had."

Photo Gallery